"nosmp" freezes SMP machine

From: Valentijn Sessink (valentyn@nospam.openoffice.nl)
Date: Fri Mar 17 2000 - 06:12:57 EST

  • Next message: Gregory Maxwell: "Re: Shadow password authentication on Linux"

    Hello Linux-kernel,

    If I start an SMP kernel with the "nosmp" option, it locks within 5
    minutes with very little load.

    Others are way more stable: a UP kernel seems just really stable. An SMP
    kernel makes it unstable but workable (and it *is* a BP6 board so
    instability may be inherent). An SMP kernel with the "nosmp" option will
    lock the machine by doing something like starting X, then start netscape
    or so. The strange fact is that it starts with hanging keyboard and
    mouse, but will let you log in remotely and/or kill X; but the keyboard
    remains dead (tried "kbdrate" and unplugging, to no avail). Then the
    eth0 hang too, another time I had just enough time to do a remote
    reboot.

    I would guess the "nosmp" option should work like a UP kernel, not like
    this, should it?

    As said: a UP kernel is *stable*, whatever I try.

    A normal SMP kernel is unstable but it takes more effort to show this:
    something like cp -av /mnt/hd0 /mnt/hd1 will work - mostly. It stops
    with an DMA timeout and a few seconds later, it freezes. "noapic"
    doesn't help.

    I also saw a couple of messages from people that had *SCSI* drives.
    Those started resetting. Could these two facts be related? It seems to
    look like some type of bug in the SMP code...

    Now I *do* have a BP6 board, but this still does not explain the easy
    lock with "nosmp".

    Details:
    2.2.15pre14 with ide.2.2.15pre13
    BP6, 2x Celeron 466, 128Mb. 15G with HPT366. Matrox, Epic100 and
    inactive SB16. No shared PCI interrupts (9, 10, 11, 12).

    Best regards,

    Valentijn
    (tried to subscribe to linux-kernel but got no response... is that
    normal?)

    --
    

    - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to majordomo@vger.rutgers.edu Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Sat Mar 18 2000 - 05:51:32 EST